Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Wauwatosa, WI & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Wauwatosa, WI

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 16.44%
Erie A+ 4.46%
Allstate A+ 4.22%
Liberty Mutual A 3.91%
GEICO A++ 3.64%

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Wauwatosa, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Joshua E Matthews Insurance Agency Inc. 15350 W NATIONAL AVE SUITE 119
www.jmatthewsinsurance.com 53151
262-785-9411
Matthews Insurance & Financial Services Inc. 39070 N Green Bay Road
www.matthewsinsuranceonline.com 60087-1907
(847) 746-8770
Pelnik Insurance 11204 W Greenfield Ave
53214
(414) 771-1380
Nesmith Insurance Agency 100 N CORPORATE DR
www.nesmithinsuranceagency.com 53045
(262) 439-4700
Vaughan Insurance Agency Inc 10335 N Port Washington Rd
53092
Bob Brown Insurance Agency Llc 3232 W Loomis Rd
53221-1141
414-325-9440
Kinston Insurance Service Agency Inc 12660 WEST CAPITOL DR #205
53005
262-782-3001
Kenneth P Faust 8660 S MARKETPLACE
53154
414-571-7146
Enloe Insurance Agency Inc. 708 W Rollins Rd
lenoirinsurance.com 60073
(847) 546-1900
Pemberton Insurance & Benefits 12065 W Janesville Rd Ste 201
53130
(414) 525-1111

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Wauwatosa, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Bob Meyer 10721 W Capitol Dr Ste 127
53222-1210
414-527-4288
Joshua Brown 2312 N GRANDVIEW BLVD STE 206
53188
262-547-7965
Rocky Mankin 2730 Sheridan Rd Ste B
60099
(847) 246-4125
Davis-Vernon Agy 601 Ryan St Ste E
53072
(262) 695-1600
James Sullivan Agy 123 N SPRING ST
53916
920-887-1615
Sarah Kieffer 148 E Wisconsin Avenue
53066
Pell City Ins Agency 15885 W National Ave Ste 300
53151
(262) 395-7768
Chad Watts 57 S Main St
53027-1866
262-673-3333
Kenneth Mosteller 1300 S GREEN BAY RD STE 300
53406
262-636-1860
Scott Black 4508 N 92nd Street # 1
53225

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Wauwatosa, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Caesar Blue 111 E Forest Hill Ave Stop B
53154-3090
414-762-3300
Email:cblue@geico.com

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Wauwatosa, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Charles Krienke N86W14041 Beacon St Ste B
53051-3246
262-255-0400
Kinyatta Wright 15300 W CAPITOL DR
53005
262-432-7800
Jeremy T. Brooks 214 EAST MILL ST
53073
920-893-2081
Steve Kundert N19 W24200 Riverwood Dr #140 Waukesha
53188
Suhail Ahmad 7997 S. Loomis Road Suite B Wind\u00a0Lake
53185
(262) 757-6746
Jeremy Thiessen 433 E MILL ST STE C
53073
920-893-8411
Brittany Romley 2304 N Grandview Blvd
53188-1602
262-544-1500
Peggy Mcintosh 1285 Sunnyridge Rd
53072
(262) 691-2288
Kip M Okinaka 1930 N MARTIN LUTHER KING DR
53212
414-264-1400
Scott Hinrichs Lutcf 14260 W Greenfield Avenue Suite 100
53005

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Wauwatosa, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Peggy Lynch N64w24678 Main St
53089
(262) 246-8115
Don Near 304 N Main St
www.donnear.com 53027
(262) 673-7975
Scott Bird 6830 W Villard Avenue Suite 160
www.scottbirdinsurance.com 53218
Sarah Johnson 1142 Bluestem Court
www.insurewithsarah.com 53121
Tamaris Lott 117 Oakridge Ct.
www.tamarislott.net 53094
(920) 278-5754
Todd Thomas 223 N Rte 21 Ste 10
www.toddthomasagency.com 60031
Raleigh Collins Jr 36104 N Green Bay Rd
www.raleighcollins.com 60087
(847) 249-4610
Larry Sifuentes 333 BISHOPS WAY STE 104
53005
262-789-7400
Dawn Sullivan 473 Park Ave Ste 500
www.dawnsullivan.net 60046
(847) 356-8900
Allan Cheng 4325 S 60th St Ste 3
www.myfinancialfuture.biz 53220-3508
414-431-1413

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Wauwatosa, WI

ErieState FarmAllstate
Median Home Value ($) 214,480224,480204,480
Construction year 196819641943
Home Coverage ($) $125000-$150000$150000-$175000$150000-$175000
Total Premium ($) $1059$1275$1229

Wauwatosa, WI Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Erie upto 16%
Allstate upto 24%
GEICO upto 18%
Liberty Mutual upto 15%