Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Milwaukee, WI & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Milwaukee, WI

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 16.44%
Travelers A++ 8%
Erie A+ 4.46%
Allstate A+ 4.22%
GEICO A++ 3.64%

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Milwaukee, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Pemberton Insurance & Benefits 12065 W Janesville Rd Ste 201
53130
(414) 525-1111
Pelnik Insurance 11204 W Greenfield Ave
53214
(414) 771-1380
Vaughan Insurance Agency Inc 10335 N Port Washington Rd
53092
Corbett Insurance 255 S Main Street
53013-1311
920-668-6932
The Kerr Agency Inc. N19W24101 Riverwood Dr
53188
Joshua E Matthews Insurance Agency Inc. 15350 W NATIONAL AVE SUITE 119
www.jmatthewsinsurance.com 53151
262-785-9411
Kinston Insurance Service Agency Inc 12660 WEST CAPITOL DR #205
53005
262-782-3001
Matthews Insurance & Financial Services Inc. 39070 N Green Bay Road
www.matthewsinsuranceonline.com 60087-1907
(847) 746-8770
Nesmith Insurance Agency 100 N CORPORATE DR
www.nesmithinsuranceagency.com 53045
(262) 439-4700
Enloe Insurance Agency Inc. 708 W Rollins Rd
lenoirinsurance.com 60073
(847) 546-1900

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Milwaukee, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Shane Tressler 8131 W Capitol Drive
www.shanetressler.com 53222
John Skariot 17100 W Bluemound Rd Ste 200
53005
Glen Monroe 473 Park Ave Ste 500
www.glenmonroe.com 60046
(847) 356-8900
Larry D. Smith 400 N EXECUTIVE DR STE 300
53005
262-780-3120
Bill Hicks 3404 Roosevelt Rd
www.hicksagency.com 53142-3937
262-656-1414
Steve Strange 640 West Main Street 640 West Main Street Lake\u00a0Geneva
53147
Sean O'Hagan 504 S 14th Street
www.seanohaganinsurance.com 53081
Nathan Smith 759 N MILWAUKEE ST
www.lakemichigansf.com 53202
414-271-7517
Chris Lair 6423 W North Ave
www.chrislairagency.com 53213-2014
414-443-1040
Dan Schroeder 315 East Main Street
www.danjschroeder.com 53094-3708
920-206-0483

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Milwaukee, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Caesar Blue 111 E Forest Hill Ave Stop B
53154-3090
414-762-3300
Email:cblue@geico.com

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Milwaukee, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Joshua D. Crow S76 W18180 JANESVILLE RD
53150
262-679-1511
Davis-Vernon Agy 601 Ryan St Ste E
53072
(262) 695-1600
Roger Lee Harness 2058 E Grand Ave Ste 11
60046
(847) 356-5560
Douglas Perkins S30w24896 Sunset Dr Ste 104
53189
(262) 548-3800
Bob Meyer 10721 W Capitol Dr Ste 127
53222-1210
414-527-4288
David Guthrie 35 N Whitney
60030-3605
847-223-1133
Pegram Insurance 11203 N Buntrock Ave
53092
(262) 250-8518
Kenneth Marcus 6303 75TH ST
53142
262-697-9600
Bill Mcdonald 3005 S 12th St
53081-6749
920-452-2482
Peggy Phifer N88w15125 Main St Ste 102
53051
(262) 293-3765

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Milwaukee, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Silver Coast Auto Insurance Inc 13035 West Bluemound Road
53005
Arthur J Gallagher & Risk Management Services 266 N Main St
www.spataroins.com 53092-1618
262-242-2700
Email:cynthia-antoinette@ajg.com
Goss & Mclain Insurance Agcy 612 S Wells St Ste F
53147
(262) 248-0861
Georgia Farm Bureau Brokerage Inc 4262 Old Grand Ave Ste D
60031
(847) 623-2300
Butch Veazey & Associates 21150 W Capitol Dr Ste 1
53072-2913
262-781-2700
Wells Fargo Ins Services Usa Inc 333 E. Wisconsin Ave
www.wellsfargo.com 53202
(844) 431-3765
Email:barbara.costa@wellsfargo.com
Claude Reynolds Insurance Agency Inc 11429 W Bluemound Rd
53226-4031
414-258-2558
Pegram Insurance 16800 W Greenfield Ave Ste 105
53005
(262) 641-8820
Lawley Service 11400 W BLUEMOUND RD
www.lawleyinsurance.com 53226
414-258-1302
Action Auto Agency 14027 W Greenfield Ave
53151-1639
262-786-7638

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Milwaukee, WI

AllstateErieTravelers
Median Home Value ($) 114,220104,220114,220
Construction year 194219621949
Home Coverage ($) $250000-$300000$250000-$300000$300000-$350000
Total Premium ($) $1176$940$1228

Milwaukee, WI Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Erie upto 21%
GEICO upto 20%
Allstate upto 23%
Travelers upto 8%