Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Jefferson County, WI & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Jefferson County, WI

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 16.44%
Travelers A++ 8%
Nationwide A+ 7%
Erie A+ 4.46%
GEICO A++ 3.64%

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Jefferson County, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Pelkofsky Insurance 11040 W Bluemound Rd Ste 214
53226
(414) 259-0670
James Swiniuch Agency Inc 121 WILLIAMS ST
53956
920-326-3223
Email:jamesswiniuch@yahoo.com
Cooper Simms Nelson & Mosley Inc N64W22652 Main Street
www.coopersimms.com 53089-3035
262-820-3300
Email:info@coopersimms.com
Pencor Northwest Inc 6402 Odana Rd Ste 3
53719
(608) 630-9776
Ryan-Reum Insurance Agency Inc 435 Village Walk Lane Suite 1-A
www.ryanreuminsurance.com 53038
Schratz Insurance Agency Po Box 135
www.schratzinsurance.com 53182

Email:Robert@SchratzInsurance.com
W R Sims Agency Inc 513 First Street
53574
Richard E Rivera Associates Inc 11953 Main St
61073
(815) 270-1067
Email:RERiveraAssociates@gmail.com
Western Insurance Services 4260 S Howell Ave
53207

Email:kj@westerninsuranceservices.com
Valley Ins Partners Llc 930 Road
53122
(262) 649-5633

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Jefferson County, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Larry D Blankenship 405 N CALHOUN ROAD SUITE 203
53005
262-784-0990
Dockery & Associates Inc 810 Cardinal Ln Ste 230
53029
(262) 361-4605
Stan Prajzner Inc P O Box 38
53185
(262) 757-7231
William A Gresko W239 N3490 Pewaukee Rd W239 N3490 Pewaukee Rd Pewaukee
53072
Mullings & Associates Insurance Llc 101 ALPINE PKWY STE 101
53575
(608) 835-7300
Sean Quill Insurance Llc 12336 W Layton Avenue Suite 6
53228
Nathan R Grant Agency 2315 10TH AVE STE 105
53172
(414) 762-8900
James T Harris 3018 W WASHINGTON ST
53095
262-334-2500
Casey Brougham Agency 7273 Highway 50
53147-4517
262-248-4771
Williams Insurance Group Llc 330 E Kilbourn Ave, Ste 650
53202
(844) 429-8427

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Jefferson County, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Caesar Blue 111 E Forest Hill Ave Stop B
53154-3090
414-762-3300
Email:cblue@geico.com

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Jefferson County, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Curt Garrett 8241 South 27th Street
53132-9310
414-761-6060
Tod Weder 6709 Raymond Road Dane
53719
Steve Strange 640 West Main Street 640 West Main Street Lake\u00a0Geneva
53147
Tamaris Lott 117 Oakridge Ct.
www.tamarislott.net 53094
(920) 278-5754
Ken Sutton 16805 W Cleveland Ave New\u00a0Berlin
53151
Eli Slesk 4706 Cottage Grove Rd Ste 300
www.elislesk.com 53716
(608) 222-2411
Dale Viniard 220 Silver Lake Street
www.daleviniardins.com 53066-3723
262-567-3443
John Stockmal 525 JUNCTION RD
www.johnstockmal.com 53717
608-203-3880
Larry Sifuentes 333 BISHOPS WAY STE 104
53005
262-789-7400
Brent Whitlock 821 E Milwaukee St
www.brentwhitlock.com 53190-2126
262-473-2380

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Jefferson County, WI

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Nesmith Insurance Agency 100 N CORPORATE DR
www.nesmithinsuranceagency.com 53045
(262) 439-4700
Ripley Insurance Centre 215 W Court St Ste 201
53548
(608) 756-3429
Brosky Insurance Agency Inc. 4182 N Perryville Rd
61111-8647
815-654-5433
Pelnik Insurance 724 E Main St
www.pelnik.com 53589
(608) 873-4695
Kinston Insurance Service Agency Inc 12660 WEST CAPITOL DR #205
53005
262-782-3001
Bob Brown Insurance Agency Llc 3232 W Loomis Rd
53221-1141
414-325-9440
Vaughan Insurance Agency Inc 10335 N Port Washington Rd
53092
Kenneth P Faust 8660 S MARKETPLACE
53154
414-571-7146
Pence Brooks & Shepherd Insurance 5555 Odana Rd Ste 201
53719
(608) 278-7055
Family First Insurance Llc 6510 Grand Teton Plz Ste 202
www.family1stllc.com 53719
(608) 274-7575

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Jefferson County, WI

NationwideGEICOState Farm
Median Home Value ($) 189,750169,750159,750
Construction year 198819442001
Home Coverage ($) $250000-$300000$200000-$250000$250000-$300000
Total Premium ($) $854$838$1027

Jefferson County, WI Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Travelers upto 9%
Nationwide upto 5%
GEICO upto 19%
Erie upto 17%